By Charles Lee Mathews. Nahana has merged a 100-year-old creative agency with an audience-first media agency on one argument: clients no longer care who does what. Integration specialists warn that the real work starts after launch.
Nahana Communications Group has combined FCB Africa and media agency Meta Media into HUMANTRUTH, a hybrid that puts creative and media under one roof.
Chris Botha, group managing director of Park Advertising, a sister agency within Nahana, says the split between the two disciplines no longer makes sense. “The single biggest indicator of digital media performance is creative. Yet we as agencies separate the function? Makes no sense. Media agencies offer creative services, and creative agencies offer media. Everyone is fighting for their share of the pie and the lines are getting blurrier,” he notes.
👉 Read more Interview: Kagiso Musi on building creative commerce agencies (Nov 2024)
Thumiso Masoha, the new managing director and former chief experience officer and MD of FCB Africa, says the name reflects the strategy. “The name comes from our belief that brands grow when they earn meaningful attention. In a world with more data, AI, content and channels than ever, we think understanding how to connect, resonate and keep engaging becomes more important, not less. Our position is to make that understanding commercially useful and turn attention and behaviour into compounding growth,” says Masoha.
His new-business pitch leaves out the agency itself. “I don’t think our starting point should be selling HUMANTRUTH; it should be understanding the growth problems businesses are trying to solve,” he says. He wants the agency involved before a brief exists, tracking how clients’ customers are changing and then assembling whatever skills the problem calls for. “If we can repeatedly turn those interventions into better decisions and measurable growth for our current clients, that becomes the most credible new business story we can tell,” Masoha says.
The org chart is still being drawn
For existing clients, Botha says the instruction is continuity. “The starting point is that clients should experience more value, not disruption. We are managing the transition relationship by relationship, protecting the teams, knowledge, and delivery clients already trust while adding capability where it genuinely adds value. So far so good,” he says.
Inside, even Botha’s own role is still taking shape. “We are kinda figuring that out as we go along. Broadly though, my role is to help create the conditions for HUMANTRUTH to succeed, while giving Thumiso and the leadership team the space and authority to build it.”
Of Masoha, he says: “Thumiso has the rare combination of strategic depth, creative instinct, commercial understanding and the ability to bring very different kinds of people together. And he is just a flippen nice, smart guy.”. Kagiso Tshepe is chief creative officer; Nahana will name the rest of the leadership team once it finalises its structure.
The rest of the group stays as is, Botha says, with Park Advertising and The MediaShop carrying on unchanged. Nahana now holds “a specialist media agency [The Media Shop], a specialist creative agency [McCann], a truly integrated hybrid agency [HUMANTRUTH],” he adds. In effect, it is backing all three agency models at once.
One operating system, two cultures
Botha says the merger was not designed to reduce headcount, but he does not rule out job losses. “As these two businesses are quite different and have unique skill sets, the risk should be minimal,” he says.
He explains that neither culture is being asked to give way. “Meta Media brings a deeply entrepreneurial, audience-first and data-led culture, while FCB Africa brings extraordinary strength in creativity, brand building and strategic thinking. We have built an operating system that honours and amplifies the best of both, rather than asking one culture to absorb the other.”
New name, old business?
Absorption is exactly the outcome integration specialists warn about. Lynn Madeley, CEO of High Performance Matters, says companies must build a new culture, not blend cultures. “For a merger presented as something genuinely new, you cannot simply ‘merge’ two cultures. You must deliberately create a future culture and operating model. Otherwise, one legacy business quietly wins, the other is absorbed,” she says.
Gillian Rightford, managing director of Adtherapy and executive director of the Association for Communication and Advertising (ACA), says shared ownership helps, but the fault line may sit elsewhere. “In this case they know each other well and were part of the same group, so it shouldn’t be as hard as two totally different entities coming together, but this may be a difference of a bigger corporate culture versus a smaller entrepreneurial culture,” says Rightford.
Her advice is harder-edged than Nahana’s. “Leadership must be clear about culture and their ambition. They must also be clear that not everyone will be the right fit,” Rightford says.
The 27-point listening gap
Rightford puts the burden on the top team, which she says must be “aligned on a new vision, if there is a new vision”. “If the leadership team has members from both, there has to be alignment; the rest of the company will suffer if there isn’t. The fish rots from the head,” she says.
Madeley would measure the integration as seriously as the billings, from key-talent retention to decision speed. “HUMANTRUTH has an unusual opportunity. It can become the genuinely integrated, African-built business it has described, rather than two agencies sharing a logo and a cost base. But the new culture will not emerge from optimism. It must be designed, led, funded, listened into existence and reinforced through the operating model,” she says.
Masoha doesn’t sugarcoat statements about the road ahead. “I wouldn’t pretend it will all be smooth sailing; meaningful change rarely is. The important thing is clarity about why we’re doing it, honesty about what is changing, and involving people in building the new business rather than simply announcing it to them,” he says.
On paper, HUMANTRUTH holds every link in the chain: strategy, creative, production, and media planning and buying. It pairs FCB Africa’s brand building with Meta Media’s audience data and behavioural insight. The org chart can deliver the structure, but only the culture can deliver the prize. An agency named for understanding people will be judged first on how well it understands its own.
Charles Lee Mathews is a senior editor to MarkLives MEDIA and a senior writer to MarkLives.com, as well as co-founder of The Writers, a writing consultancy.
